Short-term-rental rules
Can you Airbnb in Middletown, NY?
Researched and reviewed by Jake Lee, FounderCurrent as of July 2026How this atlas is maintained
The City of Middletown bans short-term rentals of residential property for stays under 30 days in every zoning district, and the city will not issue rental permits for stays that short. The only pathway is a narrow downtown carve-out: a few specific street segments in the DMU Downtown Mixed-Use District, where an STR needs a special use permit and site plan approval from the Planning Board plus a city rental permit. A typical whole-home Airbnb in a residential neighborhood is unlawful here.
What the rules say in Middletown
- Section 475-35-1: short-term rental of a residential property or any portion of it for less than 30 days is prohibited in all zoning districts in the City of Middletown.
- Exemptions to the ban: legally operating commercial hotels and motels; rentals during declared emergencies with permission from the Commissioner of Public Works; family members granted use of the premises without charge.
- Sections 296-18(C) and 296-36(C) (Housing): no rental permit may be issued for rentals of less than 30 days, except as provided in Section 475-35-1 and Section 475-21.1F(24) of the Zoning Code.
- Downtown carve-out, Section 475-21.1F(24): STRs are a use requiring both a special use permit and site plan approval by the Planning Board, only in the DMU Downtown Mixed-Use District on defined street segments (West Main St from 75 West Main to James St, James St to Depot St, Depot St to North St, North St to Erie Way excluding 90 North St, Erie Way to Cottage St, and Cottage St to Prince St).
- Carve-out conditions: the rental must run through membership or approval by an entity such as Airbnb or VRBO (or another Planning Board approved entity with standards such as insurance), and the owner must obtain and renew a rental permit under Section 296-18(C); permits are subject to Chapter 296 Article III (Rooming, Lodging and Multiple Dwelling Units) except the background check provision 296-20(H).
Sources: City of Middletown ordinance adding Zoning Code 475-35-1 (STR ban) and Housing 296-18/296-36 permit prohibition (official city PDF); Common Council resolution adding 475-21.1F(24), the DMU downtown STR special-use carve-out (Middletown BID document center PDF). Last reviewed 2026-07.
How short-term rentals are regulated in New York
- New York has no single statewide short-term-rental ban. Towns, villages, and cities set their own rules through local ordinances and zoning, so rules can differ sharply between neighboring municipalities in the same county.
- Short stays in New York are generally subject to state and local sales tax, and many counties add a local occupancy (hotel/motel) tax, often collected by the booking platform on the host's behalf.
- Common local controls include permits or registration, primary-residence requirements, and zoning limits on which districts allow short-term use. In New York, a town and a village inside it can each have their own rule.
- Rules change. An ordinance can be added or amended at any time. Always confirm the current rule with the municipality before listing.
Middletown short-term-rental FAQ
Can I run a short-term rental (Airbnb) in Middletown, NY?
The City of Middletown bans short-term rentals of residential property for stays under 30 days in every zoning district, and the city will not issue rental permits for stays that short. The only pathway is a narrow downtown carve-out: a few specific street segments in the DMU Downtown Mixed-Use District, where an STR needs a special use permit and site plan approval from the Planning Board plus a city rental permit. A typical whole-home Airbnb in a residential neighborhood is unlawful here.
Do I need a permit or registration to run an STR in Middletown?
Sections 296-18(C) and 296-36(C) (Housing): no rental permit may be issued for rentals of less than 30 days, except as provided in Section 475-35-1 and Section 475-21.1F(24) of the Zoning Code.
What taxes apply to a short-term rental in Middletown, New York?
Short-term stays in New York are generally subject to state and local sales tax, and many counties add a local occupancy (hotel) tax, often collected for you by the booking platform. A tax professional can confirm what applies to your property.
Can Palisade Stays manage a short-term rental in Middletown?
Short-term rentals face real limits in Middletown (see the status above), so it may not be the right play. Palisade Stays can still help you understand what's possible for your property, including a compliant mid-term or longer rental, and run it if it's a fit. Start with a quick assessment.
Navigating Middletown's rules?
We'll help you find out what's actually possible for your Middletown property, short-term, mid-term, or otherwise, and run it if it's a fit.
Nearby Orange towns